In a shocking attempt, emails have recently come to light that show Apple’s attempts to prevent Netflix from dropping App Store In-App Purchase support. This email exchange, between the two companies, provides insight into Apple’s attempts to persuade Netflix to stay within the App Store despite Netflix’s growing dissatisfaction with the App Store’s in-app purchase revenue sharing. This article will take a closer look at the emails and discuss how this could affect the two companies.
Emails Reveal Apple’s Attempts to Stop Netflix From Dropping App Store In-App Purchase Support
On July 17, 2019 Apple sent an email to Netflix imploring them to remain on the App Store. This action was taken as Netflix had begun informing its users that they were phasing out the iTunes billing option and withdrawing from the App Store due to Apple’s 30% cut of all in-app purchases.
The email, signed by Eddy Cue – Senior Vice President of Apple’s Internet Software and Services – emphasised its long-term relationship with Netflix, sympathised with the difficult decision it was making for its users, and rationalised Apple’s intentions for taking a cut of all in-app purchases.
In what is thought of as an act of desperation from Apple, Cue argues that ‘Apple is unlike other platforms’ because it ‘treats all developers equally’ and thus differences in how apps monetize cannot be tweaked within specific apps like they can be on other computing platforms (e.g: Android). He asks why a seemingly fair payment structure should lead to ‘restrictions’ by any platform. Regardless, he ends with his plea for Netflix to stay on the App Store.
Apple’s Attempts to Stop Netflix from Dropping App Store In-App Purchase Support
Emails recently revealed Apple’s attempts to stop Netflix from dropping App Store In-App Purchase support. The emails, released via a court filing, presented correspondence between Apple and Netflix in the summer of 2019 when the streaming giant was trying to remove the ability of users to pay for a subscription through the app.
The emails shed light on Apple’s concern about the consequences of Netflix’s decision and the tech giant’s determined effort to prevent the company from leaving the App Store.
Apple’s Emails to Netflix
Due to Apple’s App Store commission policy, Netflix recently announced that it was dropping in-app purchases for subscriptions from its mobile app, prompting a response from Apple. The tech giant sent several emails to the entertainment giant asking them not to leave the App Store, while also offering to discuss how they could modify their approach.
The emails began with requests for Netflix and Apple to “work together” on a model that allowed customers to pay for Netflix subscriptions through the App Store, while giving them a fair share of each sale. In addition, they reiterated the importance of keeping customers safe and secure when using the App Store.
Apple then highlighted some possible solutions that would enable both parties to benefit from an in-app purchase model, and discussed ways in which both companies could have “reasonable expectations” regarding customer safety and security. Finally, they requested that Netflix keep its customers apprised of any changes ahead of their launch date.
In addition to this email campaign, Apple has also said publicly that it supports subscription businesses like Netflix who use in-app purchase tools and want a fair share of sales through the App Store; however, they insist that third-party apps should not be paying more than what is necessary in order empower all types of services (including subscription ones) within apps available on their platform.
Apple’s Threats and Warnings
When Netflix announced their intent to stop using Apple’s in-app purchase system for its streaming service, Apple wasted no time in sending a stern letter to Netflix as a warning. The letter mentioned consequences for violating Apple’s terms and conditions by using an alternative payment model and played into what legal experts have termed “strong-arm tactics”.
Apple warned Netflix that its decision to pull out of the App Store could result in their experience being degraded from an end user perspective. These hints of possible negative consequences were considered more threatening than they were suggestive due to lack of specifics. It mentions that past decisions have led to “disruptions with other apps” and even “impacts on overall customer satisfaction” – not specific enough to determine what could happen until after making the move away from In-App Purchase support.
Not only was this warning intended to urge the streaming giant to rethink its decision, but it was also meant as a deterrent for prospective developers wanting more control over their revenue model while avoiding any inconvenience with Apple’s App Store guidelines and rules. Many app developers and industry critics saw this move as both heavy handed and an abuse of power – given that there is little room for negotiation or compromise regarding pricing policies on items sold within the iOS platform –a product which apps owe 90% or more of their success
The intent of this email seems clear: Keep your business with us or face consequences from both a user experience level and public image standpoint. Whether such tactics will be effective remains to be seen; however, many app developers feel increasingly vulnerable in light of such strong-arm moves made by giant tech companies like Apple – greatly limiting the once empowering scope held by app makers just a few years ago when many opportunities were open through digital products offered only on mobile devices.
Netflix’s Response to Apple’s Emails
The emails between Apple and Netflix show Apple’s attempts to keep Netflix from dropping In-App Purchase support from the App Store. Apple was pushing Netflix to continue payments through its App Store to maintain a 30% owner’s fee. However, Netflix decided to respond to this pressure and stick to its guns. Let’s look at Netflix’s response to Apple’s emails and what it means for the future of the App Store.
Netflix’s Refusal to Comply
Netflix refused to comply with Apple’s demand to pay Apple a 15 to 30 percent commission and reluctantly decided to pull their app from the App Store. In a statement, Netflix said that “Apple’s terms disadvantage other app developers and dramatically inflate prices for consumers.” As part of this decision, Netflix also chose not to extend deals for customers that it had previously offered through the Apple App Store.
The decision stems from a disagreement between the two companies over money and how much authority Apple would have over Netflix’s content and marketing activities. By pulling out of the App Store, Netflix could take back control of its destiny in terms of customer acquisition and setting its price points without having to adhere to any restrictions imposed by Apple.
Though it is uncertain what ultimately made Netflix decide not to submit an update containing In-App Purchase capability to comply with App Store guidelines, it can be said that this decision helped protect the company’s business model and consumers’ interests. It may even be considered a landmark moment for software companies fighting against policies that limit their ability to innovate and positively influence society by providing high-quality services at competitive prices.
Netflix’s Decision to Leave The App Store
Netflix decided not to renew its licence to sell subscriptions through Apple’s App Store. As a result, the direct purchase option for existing and prospective customers was terminated in December 2020.
Apple emailed the streaming giant about its “apparent decision to no longer make Netflix available for purchase in the app store” and added that it would be “disappointing to see Netflix leave the app store.” However, despite Apple’s pleas, Netflix continued with its plan to move away from the App Store payments system.
Netflix acknowledged, however, that its decision will not impact all users of the service. For example, customers who purchased a subscription before December of 2020 could still access their account via the Apple version of Netflix, after converting their subscription using in-app payments on the platform itself or using other payment methods.
Netflix also stated that iOS customers can use various alternate payment methods within the Netflix app, including credit & debit cards, PayPal, Google Pay and select carrier billing options (where applicable). As part of this new subscription process change, customers can still give a Netflix subscription if they wish by purchasing directly via netflix.com/gift on desktop or mobile web.
Conclusion
The emails show that Apple was dissatisfied with Netflix’s decision to drop in-app purchase support from its iOS app. Apple wants developers to use in-app purchases to generate more revenue and seeing an established company like Netflix dropping the feature was concerning. It’s clear that Apple is trying to protect its business model, but it’s not clear if it will succeed in the long term. This conclusion will dive deeper into the implications of Apple’s attempts to keep Netflix and other companies from removing in-app purchase features.
Summary of The Emails
Apple’s email to Netflix provides an insight into the technology giant’s efforts to keep the streaming service from leaving the App Store. The company stressed its long-standing relationship with Netflix, citing its contributions to Apple products, services, and customer satisfaction. Apple also highlighted its commitment to creating a fair and level playing field for all app developers on the App Store.
In the email, Apple requested that Netflix remain to ensure customers continue having access to their favourite streaming entertainment. Additionally, Apple offered several suggestions on how developers can improve their experience on the platform and gain more visibility. Finally, Apple reminded developers of the benefits they receive while being part of the App Store community such as promotional opportunities and analytics that allow app creators to understand how their offerings are performing relative to others on iTunes and in conjunction with other apps.
Apple’s email demonstrates a commitment to fostering an environment in which all members can benefit from being part of an innovative ecosystem. By emphasising their partnership with Netflix while providing practical strategies for success, Apple illustrated their dedication to helping developers succeed on their platform while protecting and defending their interests.
Implications of The Emails
The exchange of emails between Apple and Netflix shows that the two companies have been at odds with one another. It also suggests that Apple knows the legal implications of preventing Netflix from leaving its app store.
Apple’s email to Netflix states: “We are disappointed that you have put us in this position… However, suppose a company cannot conveniently offer customers the option to purchase digital content within an app. In that case, it ultimately harms consumers, who may be forced to easily find a competitive offering from another source, or worse, not find it at all.”
This statement reflects Apple’s significant power over other technology companies through its app store. In addition, by taking such a hard-line stance, Apple is showcasing its ability to control what content companies can distribute on its platform. Despite the potential legal repercussions associated with maintaining this stance, the fact remains that Apple can still prevent companies like Netflix from leaving their app stores if they don’t accept their terms — terms which benefit Apple more heavily than they benefit the third-party company.
The emails also reveal how dependent technology companies are on dealing with larger giants such as Apple when attempting to reach out to consumers through mobile devices; by turning down one offer and potentially losing access completely (without any warning), it indicates how dependent these tech companies can be on third-party platforms such as App Stores. Additionally, these emails demonstrate how little power individual companies have when facing giant tech firms and how imbalanced bargaining power can often affect decisions made by small firms.
tags = netflix, streaming service, apple app store, apple in-app purchases, iapple in-app payment system, netflix subscription fee, netflix iaps apple netflixmiller9to5mac, netflix apple apple netflixmiller9to5mac, apple iaps apple netflixmiller9to5mac, iaps apple netflixmiller9to5mac, apple iaps netflixmiller9to5mac, apple and netflix, top streaming service, netflix ios app